Delaware was the first State to legislate the privacy of students' social-media passwords. California's legislature was the first and, so far, the only State to pass a bill that protects students' and employees' social-networking passwords. That bill is awaiting the signature of California's Governor. For more information about the California law, check out this great post at Seyfarth Shaw's Trading Secrets blog in which the authors were nice enough to mention my previous post on the topic. (Even if they did call me by [gasp] my legal name, Margaret. It's not their fault my parents couldn't pick just one name and stick with it.)
But a state statute is not necessarily the only way to protect students' free-speech and privacy rights in their online content. As reported by blawgger extraordinaire,Venkat Balasubrami, and, subsequently, by GigaOm.com, a federal judge in Minnesota recently held that a school violated a 12-year-old student's First Amendment rights when it cooerced her into turning over her Facebook password so school administrators could investigate comments the girl was alleged to have made.
Although schools' access to students' social-media accounts may be the hot topic du jour but it's not the first. For about as long as Facebook has been around, teachers have been getting into trouble for what the post on it. One of the most distasteful types of posts are those in which a teacher criticizes his or her students.
Long-time readers and Philadelphia-area natives may recall the story of Natalie Munroe, an AP English teacher who was suspended after parents and students discovered posts she'd written, mocking and demoralizing the youths in her class.
A story was recently reported in North Carolina, where a high-school teacher was suspended pending an investigation involving simlar allegations. The English teacher is alleged to have posted photos of her students' works, highlighting the grammar gaffes and misspellings and making fun of their mistakes. Although her Facebook posts were not public, someone with access to them (i.e., a "Facebook Friend"), reported the photos to school officials, which prompted the investigation.
Although the stories vary slightly from one to the next, I continue to believe that the key lessons are time tested. For those who in charge who receive a complaint about a comment made online, deal with the problem for what is--no more and no less. Don't overreact and, for heaven's sake, don't make little girls cry in order to get access to their Facebook pages.
And for those who are posting, think before you do so, just like you would, hopefully, think before you speak. For teachers, don't post about a comment online about student that you wouldn't say directly to the student's parent. And, even more basic, don't mock people's weaknesses. Nobody likes a snob and grammar snobs are no exception.