What the Delaware Charge Statistics Mean for Employers

Delaware Department of Labor (DDOL) Office of Anti-Discrimination recently released its fiscal-year statistics relating to the charges filed and resolved in FY2009.  I posted previously about the stats, including some (hopefully) helpful charts that show the trends over time. 

Since the statistics were released, I’ve had some time to process the data and focus more on what is most relevant to Delaware employers.  3-24-2009 8-41-02 PM

Charges, Charges, Charges

If you are an employer who received a Notice of Charge of Discrimination for the first time in 2009, you are not alone. There were more charges filed with the DDOL last year than any other year for which the statistics are published. In FY2009, the DDOL accepted 728 charges—an increase of nearly 20% over FY2008.

Retaliation Claims Continue to Reign as Enemy #1

It may not come as a surprise that the most-often filed charge was a retaliation charge. Charges of discrimination alleging retaliation constituted more than 70% of the charges filed last year. One reason for such a high number is that retaliation is often added as a second allegation in charges alleging other types of discrimination. Also, once a charge has been filed, it can be amended to add other claims. So, if an employee files a charge alleging gender discrimination and is subsequently terminated, she is likely to amend her charge with an additional charge of retaliation.

The increase in the number of charges filed that contain a retaliation claim is staggering. In FY2008, approximately 30% of all charges filed with the DDOL contained a retaliation claim—even less in FY2005-2007. Those numbers went up by 130% over the last fiscal year. It is fair to say that retaliation claims are, by any measure, an employer’s number one biggest threat in the context of discrimination claims.

Race- and gender-based claims enjoyed equal growth over last year—both accounting for an additional 40% of all claims filed. After retaliation, race (56.9%), and gender (46.4%) discrimination ranked as the second and third most commonly filed claims.

Defining “Success”—Reasonable Cause Findings Issued in FY2009

There is some good news for employers among these statistics. Overall, there number of reasonable cause findings issued by the DDOL remains small. On average, only 1.5% of all claims filed resulted in a cause finding. The DDOL’s long investigation periods, though, may skew these numbers. Because the average processing time for a charge is nearly a year, the reasonable-cause findings issued in FY2009 were likely issued for charges filed in FY2008.

The most successful claims in FY2009 were those based on age—reasonable cause was found in just less than 4% of all age claims filed. National origin was the second-most successful, with reasonable cause findings issued in 2.5% of those claims.

No reasonable cause findings were issued in three types of claims: (1) gender discrimination claims filed by males; (2) Asian-race claims; and (3) religious-discrimination claims.

Looking Ahead

The lesson to be learned from this data for Delaware employers is this:

The increased likelihood that your organization will be named in a charge means that you must be ever diligent in documenting the events of the workplace and being on high alert for potential issues as they arise and, especially, when dealing with an employee who complains of discrimination or harassment (formally or informally).

 

Also see:

2009 Stats on Delaware Charges of Discrimination

Contact Information