Delaware Department of Labor Issues Final Regulations

The Delaware Department of Labor (DDOL), is the agency responsible for processing charges of discrimination filed under Delaware’s various discrimination statutes. Because the DDOL has a work-sharing agreement with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), the Department has authority to process charges filed under state and federal discrimination laws.image

Until now, the charge process, including applicable deadlines and controlling procedures, has not been regulated by state law. How a charge is handled by the DDOL, and the rules governing charging parties and responding employers have been available only in the form of proposed regulations for the past several years. But, last month, the DDOL published its first set of final regulations applicable to the charge process.

In this post, the new regulations are summarized and explained. A second, follow-up post will offer some commentary about these important changes.

The Charge of Discrimination

The regulations set forth what must be included in a charge of discrimination. A charge must identify:

  • the basis for the DDOL to assert jurisdiction over the charge;
  • the type(s) of discrimination alleged;
  • the type(s) of adverse action alleged;
  • the facts that support the claim;
  • the laws that have allegedly been violated; and
  • the reasons that the charging party believes support a finding of discrimination.

For the charge to be valid, the charging party must swear under oath that the allegations are true and correct and must sign the charge before a notary public.

Initial Processing of a Charge

Once a verified charge is filed, the DDOL must send a copy to the employer, by certified mail, within 14 days. The DDOL may also include a request for information with the charge, and, in its discretion, may invite the employer to participate in mediation. Even if the DDOL has not invited the employer to participate in mediation, the regulations permit the employer to request mediation in lieu of filing an answer.

The employer has 20 days to submit an answer, though the Administrator has the discretion to grant an extension of time to respond. The answer must respond “fully and completely” to the allegations asserted in the charge.

Preliminary Findings

The next step is the issuance of a preliminary finding. The Administrator must issue her preliminary finding within 60 days from the date the charge was served to the employer. The DDOL Administrator has three options. She can refer the case to mediation, refer the case for investigation, or recommend dismissal of the case.

The Administrator may dismiss a case in the following circumstances:

  • the DDOL does not have jurisdiction over the case (because, for example, the employer has too few employees to be covered by the law or the employment was not located in Delaware);
  • the charging party is not cooperating;
  • the employer has filed for bankruptcy or relief is otherwise precluded;
  • the charge was filed after the statutory deadline, or
  • the charge does not allege facts that would, even if true, constitute a violation of the law.

Administrative dismissal is rare. And, even if dismissal is recommended, the charging party will be given the opportunity to provide additional evidence demonstrating that an investigation is warranted.

Mediation

The regulations also address the DDOL mediation process. The Administrator is authorized to refer a case to mediation at any time, after 20 days from service of the charge. The regulations make clear that mediation communications and records are confidential and may not be used against either party. The regulations preclude the mediation director and staff from participating in the investigation of any case that is unsuccessfully mediated. And, if the case is settled, the settlement agreement will be kept confidential unless there is an allegation that one of the parties has breached the agreement.

Investigation

If the parties do not mediate the charge or if the mediation fails, the charge will be referred for investigation. The employer has 20 days from the date it receives notice that the case has been referred for investigation to file its answer, if it has not done so already. If the employer did file an answer, the employer will have 20 days from the date of notice of investigative referral provide a supplemental response or to respond to any pending request for information.

The regulations include a lengthy description of the DDOL’s tools for investigating claims. The DDOL’s powers include obtaining information from the employer through written requests for information and documents, on-site visits and interviews. The DDOL can obtain information from third parties with subpoenas and depositions. The DDOL also has the authority to obtain information at a fact-finding conference.

A DDOL representative advises the parties in advance of the conference to bring specified witnesses and documents. During the fact-finding conference, the DDOL representative will question the witnesses and parties. The regulations state that “the parties shall not be entitled to cross-examine witnesses,” but the representative has the discretion to allow attendees to question the witnesses.

Determination and Findings

When the DDOL concludes its investigation, the Administrator will issue a determination. The determination can state that the Administrator either did or did not find reasonable cause to believe that the employer violated the law by discriminating against the charging party. A “no-cause” finding results in a dismissal of the charge. A finding of “cause,” on the other hand, means that the Administrator has determined that there is reasonable cause to believe that the employer unlawfully discriminated against the charging party.

In the event of a “cause finding,” the employer has 10 days to file a written request for reconsideration of the finding. The Administrator will determine whether the employer will be granted permission to submit additional information in support of its request. The Administrator’s decision will be issued within 10 days of the date the request for reconsideration is made.

Conciliation

If the reasonable-cause finding is not reversed by the Administrator, it is considered final. A final cause finding triggers the conciliation process. Similar to the mediation process, conciliation provides an additional pre-litigation opportunity for the parties to resolve the dispute.

If conciliation fails and the parties do not reach agreement, the DDOL will issue a Right-to-Sue Notice to the employee, which authorizes the employee to file a complaint in state court. At that point, the DDOL’s involvement in the case concludes. The DDOL will retain its file for two years. If litigation ensues, the parties will have the right to obtain copies of the witness statements and factual written data, reports and documents in the DDOL’s file by making a written request and serving a copy of the request on the other party or the other party’s attorney.

Updated:

4 responses to “Delaware Department of Labor Issues Final Regulations”

  1. Stephen Corrado says:

    What are the rights of an employee (or laws pertaining to) when scheduled ‘on-call’ by a Delaware employer. Can an employer put you on-call several days a week and expect you to be available for their purposes? Does that not affect my ability to procure other employment, have a second job committment, or make plans for those days?

  2. Lawrence Wasserman says:

    I worked for a delaware company as an officer of the company and received an appointment letter spelling out that my compensation is in the form as a retainer. I was terminated without cause and the letter said effective postmark date of letter but effective 30 April. There was other non factual statements etc. I was told informally by the outside accountant not as an employee that this was unethical and that company was possibly avoiding paying social security taxes on not only to me but two other individuals in the same situation – BUT NOT TERMINATED.Question is the company violating Federal and State laws? Thank you!

  3. Richard Murray says:

    does s/s benifit effect

  4. This site is really a very informative site. This site gives us knowledge What are the rights of an employees. These types of information are very helpful for the people who are working in multinational companies.

Contact Information